Should it be illegal for healthy dogs to be put to sleep?

n 2018, an estimated total of 1,462 stray dogs were put to sleep across the UK – some of them for no other reason but the fact they were not claimed, and no rescue space was available for them.

By law, pounds are required to keep dogs found straying for a limited amount of time; if they remain unclaimed, they can be put up for adoption – but if no one comes forward, they may be euthanased to free up space for the next wandering stray. Rescues often race against time to save these dogs but, often already stretched to their limit, aren’t always able to help. 

It isn’t so everywhere. In some countries, such as Italy, it is illegal to put healthy dogs to sleep – pet or a stray – outside specific circumstances like severe aggression.

Some are calling for this policy to be implemented in the UK as well, arguing that no dog should be killed for no reason but lack of space to keep them. Others point out that while well-meaning, this policy of keeping all dogs indefinitely would lead to overcrowded pounds, with dogs living crammed in kennels for potentially their entire life and strays left in the streets due to the lack of space. The problems, they argue, would out outweigh the benefits. 

What do you think – should it be illegal to put a healthy dog to sleep? Write your answer to, or comment the Facebook post below.


  1. Avatar
    Christine Boulton 2 years ago

    No healthy animal should be put down.

  2. Avatar
    Helen Burton 2 years ago

    Stricter legislation regarding breeding is required.

  3. Avatar
    Georgina 2 years ago

    Vets, Rescues full to overflowing, Pound Pullers and stray kennels etc already suffer when they cannot find places for dumped dogs to go. It would be fantastic if the only strays were one or two who had genuinely escaped from a loving home but that is never going to happen – so don’t make it illegal for them to gently end the life of a dog rather than leave him or her straying in all weathers, with no food, no shelter, at risk of being injured in an accident etc.

    I would love it if there was no need for any dog who is healthy (and bear in mind a dog which appears healthy on the outside could have severe mental health problems) to be PTS, however until humans can be held accountable for any animals that have been in their care this is sadly going to be an ongoing situation.

Leave a reply to Georgina Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.